I recently obtained a copy of Sid Meier’s Railroads!.
I was originally going to write an in-depth review of the game, but there’s been so much controversy around it amongst gamers that it’s more interesting to cover that angle. (Well, it’s sort of a controversey. I have to make it sound cooler than it is.)
First, a nutshell review:

The game features a top-down interface that allows you to lay tracks, buy trains, and deliver goods and people to various cities. You also are able to purchase the basic industries in the cities (you can buy the food plant in Chicago, earning you bonus cash for every cart of grain delivered), and you can also play a simplified stock market. The basic premise is: every company has 10 stocks; if you own all 10 stocks you get all their stuff. It’s how you “win” the game - getting a profitable rail line and buying out your competitors.
It is simple in concept and the game is simple in execution. It isn’t incredibly complicated. Anyone can pick it up and play it. A good indicator is the tutorial; it lasts all of 10 minutes if you’re from the short bus, and nothing requires more than common sense to get a good feel for how to create a successful train business.
In reflection, the game is quite similar to Monopoly.
Gameplay is designed to be fast-food style: short (20-60 minute games) and fun. Online play just enhances the gameplay even more. It rapidly becomes a game of building a profitable rail network, versus buying profitable industries, versus buying your opponent’s stock. Buying out one opponent leaves you hurting for cash (at least temporarily) and open to buyouts by other players. If you invest a small amount into an opponent early on, you have less starting capital and slower growth, but the amount you pay later on to buy out your opponent is substantially less. It’s one huge game of paper-rock-scissors with the joy of laying tracks and watching trains run around on them! (which I’m convinced more people like than let on)
Now the controversey.
It seems every gamer on the planet took a look at Sid Meier’s Railroad Tycoon (released in 1990), and immediately drew the conclusion that this was a sequel, and thusly would contain enhancements to the previous version.
There are a few false premises being drawn here, which I will have to address. First, people beleive “Sid Meier’s Railroads!” is a sequel to “Railroad Tycoon 3.” Though the naming scheme appears so different as to sound like a ‘cheap knockoff,’ people still fervently beleive that Railroads! was chosen because it would sell better than simply slapping a “4″ on the previous franchise. However, this couldn’t be farther from the truth.
In Sid Meier’s Railroading career, he released his first game in 1990. The rights of the game subsequently changed hands, and the first ’sequel’ had dropped it’s moniker and moved on to a new studio. After more changing of hands, Railroads 3 was finally released in 2003, without any sort of input or approval from Sid Meiers. SM’s Railroads! was designed from the beginning to be a whole new game, hence the new name. It was a departure from the entire series, and even his own original 1990 game.
Railroads 3 was an epic game - it was very freeform, there was few set rules to gameplay, and a very detailed economic model. There was a true stock market where you could invest in goods. You could build 15 stations in a single city if you chose. You could make trains 120 cars long if you wanted to. And gameplay maps are huge in comparison. If Railroads 3 was modelled as a highly accurate, detailed world model and simulator, then Railroads! is a tabletop model railroad in grandpa’s basement that’s fun for the whole family.
So now there’s a battle raging - the simulator fans all feel they were tricked into buying this new “sequel” that is, in fact, a dumbed down model with less features and marginally better graphics. People are complaining in forums that the company is using this as a cash cow, putting in incredibly little effort into a product that will ride solely on the coattails of it’s predecessor. The constant flamewars in the forums between the “it’s fun!” and the “it’s not realistic!” communities are getting a little out of hand.
The interesting thing is, as much as people seemed to have loved Railroad Tycoon 3, Railroads! is already on track to selling more copies. People have voted with their dollars! It turns out that “fun” trumps “work.” Who would have guessed?!?!



on November 2nd, 2006 at 10:07 am #
You’d think a serious fan of this series, serious enough to get into catfights online with other fans, would have read at least one review or acquired some information on the game before taking the plunge and buying. I love coca cola, but I don’t automatically assume that everything that coke makes is going to taste like Classic.