So, while I haven’t gotten much feedback to my last two Simpsons-related posts, Hawkeye’s response to my 400th episode bashing struck a chord that has been resonating ever since. I was immediately reminded of a scene in High Fidelity between Jack Black (Barry) and John Cusack (Rob). Naturally, I couldn’t find such a small, insignificant scene on YouTube, but with the use of my near-photographic cinematic memory, I wil painstakingly recreate it for you here, now:
(A middle-aged man enters the record store hoping to buy “I Just Called to Say ‘I Love You’” for his daughter. Barry insults the man, saying there is no way his daughter likes that song, unless she is in a coma. The man leaves in a huff. This scene follows, more or less.)

Rob: Nice, Barry.
Barry: Rob, Top Five musical crimes perpetrated by Stevie Wonder in the 80’s and 90’s. Subquestion: Is it in fact unfair to criticize a formerly great artist for his later day sins… Is it better to burn out than to fade away?
That’s it… and yes, I am aware that it is a reference to a Neil Young song, but I find Jack Black’s delivery more memorable. Anyway, the point is that it got me thinking about musicians, TV shows, Movie trademarks and things of that sort that have either quit while they were ahead and faded into oblivion or stuck it out long after they lost their edge. To tell you the truth, I really can’t decide which is better.
Seinfeld, in my mind, is the ultimate example of fading away. Not that Jerry isn’t doing standup and the TV waves are glutted with syndicated re-runs, but this is the perfect example of a TV show writing staff realizing that they have nowhere to go but downhill, and getting out while they are ahead. While I am sad that I will never see a new episode, I am overwhelmed with respect for them.
Happy Days was not a show I ever enjoyed, nor did I ever watch it enough to form a legit opinion, but I bring it up here because it set the standard for burning out, so much so that the phrase “Jumping the shark” (in reference to Fonzie jumping over a shark on water skis) is now a common way of saying that a show is in decline. On that note, I just discovered a website called jumptheshark.com where people can gather to bitch about what TV shows are no good anymore. Ironically, The Simpsons is listed on the “Never Jumped the Shark” hall of fame on that site… so that shows you what I know.
I would not consider myself a huge Star Wars fan, nor would I really call the last 3 iterations burnt out, but I am of the opinion that if George Lucas had just let the first 3 stand alone and dissapeared into Skywalker Ranch for the rest of eternity, the franchise would be much more fondly remembered by history.
How about Austin Powers? #1 - Amazing. #2 - Pretty good. #3 - Piece of Shit. Should have quit while he was ahead. You can’t just have a sequel anymore though. It’s either one and done (because it sucked) or a trilogy. Ocean’s 11-12-13? The Matrix, Matrix Reloaded, Matrix Revolutions? Pirates of the Carribean…? When I heard someone mention The Bourne Ultimatum, I thought it was a joke.
In terms of musicians, you could debate this all day. I think music is a far more subjective art form than visual arts, but that’s just me. That said, I am thinking of a band like Aerosmith. The Rolling Stones are obviously not going anywhere, but you would be hard pressed to find someone who has seen them live recently who would say they are burnt out. Not that I have seen Aerosmith live or was ever a huge fan, but their last two albums of originals came out strong with lots of hype and publicity before flopping and they have released like 2 or 3 “best of’ compilations with the same friggin songs.

Also, with music, the “fade away” people usually die tragically or commit suicide, so it is harder to respect them for “choosing” to hang it up. Maybe I’m over my head talking about this, but it is the art form from which the quote originates so I felt like I had to say something.
Anyway, I am going to go out on a limb and say that it is better to fade away than to burn out. No one wants to see a tired, haggard, once-great artist, TV show, or movie franchise struggling to hold on to their youth. It’s just sad. Sure, The Matrix Revolutions was better than a lot of movies released in 2003 (2 Fast 2 Furious, Bad Boys 2, Cradle 2 the Grave, Freddy Vs. Jason, The Italian Job, Tomb Raider, S.W.A.T., etc.) but that doesn’t mean it isn’t a steaming pile of donkey shit next to the original. When someone or something has been great for so long, good just doesn’t cut it.
The Simpsons is now a good show, but unless they plan on elevating their game back to great, I would love to see them hang it up after the movie… unless it is a good movie, then they should make two more.
btw- Who said, “I’d rather be a has-been than a never-was?” Regardless, it’s good. Much love to The Simpsons and the rest for giving me so much pleasure for so long.
on May 31st, 2007 at 6:19 pm #
twin peaks is awesome - weasel and I watched the whole series after seeing mullholland drive.
Did you watched “fire walk with me” yet, or are you going to watch that after you finish the series?
on May 31st, 2007 at 6:21 pm #
I friggin love Twin Peaks. That second clip you posted is one of the most brilliant things ever televised.
You know they actually put out a book of “Laura Palmer’s Secret Diary”? It seemed pretty interesting. I bought it, but gave it to a friend as I wasn’t into Twin Peaks at the time. The shame will follow me forever.
on May 31st, 2007 at 8:28 pm #
Yes I watched and loved Twin Peaks as well. Loved it in a WHAT THE HELL IS GOING ON kind of artsy-fartsy way. Lynch is epicly surreal… force.
on June 1st, 2007 at 1:43 pm #
I debated with myself over whether to watch Fire Walk With Me before or after the series, I decided to wait. I would love to read Laura Palmer’s Secret Diary, I wonder how easy it is to find now.
on June 2nd, 2007 at 5:20 am #
Link